Compendium 16 — Lessons in Stoicism: What Ancient Philosophers Teach Us about How to Live
“It is not death that a man should fear, but he should fear never beginning to live.”― Marcus Aurelius
📖 Brief Overview
Lessons in Stoicism by John Sellars is a compelling exploration of Stoic philosophy, offering a modern lens on ancient wisdom. The book delves into the teachings of notable Stoic philosophers like Seneca, Epictetus, and Marcus Aurelius, distilling their profound ideas into practical lessons for contemporary readers. Sellars navigates the core Stoic principles, emphasizing the importance of virtue, rationality, and self-control in achieving a meaningful and tranquil life.
Sellars guides readers through key Stoic concepts, such as the dichotomy of control, which highlights the importance of focusing on what is within our power and accepting what is not. He illuminates the Stoic perspective on emotions, encouraging readers to understand and manage their feelings through rational judgment. The book also explores the Stoic approach to adversity, advocating for a mindset that embraces challenges as opportunities for growth and self-improvement.
Lessons in Stoicism is more than a historical exploration; it's a practical guide for applying Stoic principles in the complexities of modern life. Sellars bridges the ancient and the contemporary, making Stoic philosophy accessible and relevant to readers seeking wisdom in the face of life's challenges. Through concise and insightful chapters, the book equips readers with valuable tools to cultivate resilience, tranquility, and fulfillment in today's fast-paced world.
🏆 Main Takeaways
Navigating Life's Tides with Epictetus: Embracing Stoic Wisdom in a Chaotic World
Mastering Internal Control
The distinction lies between what we can control internally – our judgments, impulses, and desires – and external factors such as our bodies or possessions. Epictetus emphasizes the power of internal control, guiding us to focus on our thoughts and reactions rather than external events.
Subjectivity of Value
Epictetus challenges the notion of inherent goodness in external things. He argues that value is assigned through judgments, highlighting the subjective nature of desirability. Understanding this concept liberates us from attachment to material possessions, fostering emotional resilience.
Swift judgments can lead to biased perceptions of external objects. Cultivating mindfulness in our judgments allows for deliberate, reasoned decisions, preventing impulsive actions. By slowing down our evaluations, we make choices based on objective reasoning rather than immediate emotional responses.
Virtue as the Ultimate Guide
Epictetus believes genuine goodness resides in virtue, emanating from our judgments and actions. Embracing virtuous character becomes the cornerstone of a fulfilling life. By aligning our judgments with virtue, we make decisions that lead to personal growth and meaningful connections.
Detachment from Illusory Allure
Reflecting on the physical reality of desirable objects – recognizing a lavish meal as an animal carcass or expensive items as metal and plastic – helps detach from their illusory appeal. This practice facilitates objective judgments, guiding us toward wiser, less emotionally driven decisions.
Mastery of Judgments
Epictetus emphasizes our ability to control judgments, advocating reflective practices to overcome impulsive and unexamined assessments. By mastering our judgments, we gain autonomy over our actions and emotions, leading to a profound sense of self-control and contentment.
Vulnerability of External Dependencies
Epictetus highlights the vulnerability of relying on external factors, such as relationships, careers, or possessions, for happiness. He warns that pinning our well-being on these elements renders us susceptible to disappointment and frustration, as these aspects lie beyond our control. True contentment stems from internal mastery, not external circumstances.
Acceptance of Unalterable Realities
Stoicism encourages acceptance of immutable aspects of life, including nationality, gender, and other inherent traits. While some roles can be changed, fundamental characteristics are beyond alteration. Embracing these unchangeable facets fosters resilience and inner peace.
Control Over Actions, Not Outcomes
Epictetus emphasizes our dominion over actions but emphasizes the lack of control over outcomes. Life's unpredictability means even our best efforts might not yield desired results. Stoicism teaches that anchoring happiness to actions rather than outcomes ensures unshakable contentment, as our focus remains on doing our best rather than the uncontrollable consequences.
Acceptance of External Events
Marcus Aurelius and Epictetus emphasize the impermanence of external events and advocate acceptance of the ever-changing nature of the world. They stress the futility of resisting uncontrollable circumstances and encourage adapting to what unfolds, aligning one's mindset with the natural flux of life.
Focus on Controllable Factors
Epictetus underscores the importance of directing attention towards internal elements within our control, particularly our judgments. By refining our judgments, we enhance our character, leading to a smoother life experience. This focus on the internal realm aligns with Stoic principles, emphasizing mastery over one's thoughts and reactions.
Vigilance and Reflection
Both Marcus Aurelius and Seneca exemplify the necessity of constant vigilance and self-reflection. Marcus Aurelius engages in morning reflections, preparing himself mentally for the day's challenges, while Seneca practices evening reflection, evaluating his actions and areas for improvement. Epictetus extends this concept, advocating perpetual attentiveness to prevent lapses in judgment, highlighting the continuous nature of Stoic practice.
Emotional Mastery in Stoicism: Navigating the Inner Landscape
Understanding Stoic Emotions: The Power of Judgement and Control
The Stoic perspective on emotions revolves around the idea that emotions are the outcomes of our judgments. According to Stoic philosophy, we are entirely responsible for our emotions because they stem from the attitudes we adopt toward external events. The Stoics don't advocate repression of emotions but propose avoiding their emergence through rational judgment. However, they acknowledge that once emotions take hold, they are challenging to quell, akin to trying to stop after running too fast.
Seneca's Insight on Anger: A Temporary Madness
Seneca describes intense emotions like anger as temporary madness. He compared the overwhelming grip of anger to hurtling uncontrollably from a height, emphasizing the loss of reason in such states. Seneca stressed that we don't need anger to respond to wrongs; acting with calm resolve driven by loyalty, duty, or justice is more effective. While anger might seem motivational, Seneca argued that virtues like courage and justice should guide our actions, not volatile emotions.
Emotions as Controllable Judgments: A Stoic View
Central to Stoicism is the notion that emotions, including anger, are judgments made within the mind. These judgments lead to tangible physical symptoms like increased heart rate and sweating. While these symptoms are real, Stoicism teaches that emotions can be controlled at the level of judgment, emphasizing the importance of rational assessment to prevent emotions from spiraling out of control.
Understanding Stoic Emotions: First Movements and Judgements
Contrary to the misconception that Stoicism advocates emotional suppression, the Stoics acknowledge "first movements," instinctive physiological reactions to experiences. These initial reactions, such as feeling nervous or scared, are natural and beyond our control. However, Stoicism distinguishes them from true emotions, which occur when the mind judges an event and responds to it. Seneca emphasizes that these first movements are not emotions unless the mind judges them and acts upon them, leading to a loss of control.
Challenging Harmful Judgements: The Role of Impression
Stoic philosophy delves into the origins of harmful emotions like anger, often arising from a perceived injury. Seneca and Epictetus stress the importance of challenging the initial impression of being harmed. Epictetus highlights the necessity of pausing and reflecting before reacting impulsively to events. By questioning the validity of critical remarks and assessing their truth, one can prevent harmful emotions from taking hold. Stoicism encourages a thoughtful response over impulsive reactions, emphasizing the power of rational judgment in emotional control.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to The Scipionic Circle to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.